Apple trees and pollination: how to choose varieties that help each other

November to March is planting season for bare-root fruit trees. If you buy an apple tree now, you need to think not only about flavour but also about pollination. Most apple varieties crop poorly or not at all unless a suitable other variety flowers nearby. A few simple rules will spare you a tree full of blossom and no apples.

Why an apple needs a partner

Almost all apple varieties are largely self-sterile: pollen from the same variety germinates poorly on the stigma. Good fruit set needs pollen from a different variety, carried over by bees and other insects. Some varieties are described as (partly) self-fertile, such as Elstar, Discovery, Gala and James Grieve, but even these set more fruit with a pollinator nearby.

Conditions for good cross-pollination

  • Simultaneous flowering. Flowering must overlap; ideally there are no more than about six days between the full bloom of two varieties.
  • Good pollen. Triploid varieties are unsuitable as pollinators.
  • Distance. The closer, the better. Trees in the neighbours' garden can count.
  • Weather. In cold, wet weather bees fly little. A sheltered spot helps.

Pollination groups

Varieties are divided into flowering groups, from early to late (the British RHS uses groups 1 to 7). A variety can be pollinated by varieties from the same group or a directly adjacent group. Group 3 (mid-season flowering) includes Elstar, Cox's Orange Pippin, James Grieve, Discovery and Belle de Boskoop. The RHS places Golden Delicious and Gala in group 4, while some Dutch nurseries count them as mid-season. So always check your nursery's pollination chart.

Watch out for triploid varieties

Triploid varieties have three sets of chromosomes and produce almost no viable pollen. Well-known examples are Jonagold (and its sports), Belle de Boskoop, Bramley's Seedling, Karmijn de Sonnaville, Gravenstein and Mutsu. For these varieties:

  1. Never use them as a pollinator for another variety.
  2. Plant two diploid varieties with them, so that the triploid tree is pollinated and the two pollinators also pollinate each other.

Research by the British NIAB shows that Golden Delicious is a poor pollinator for Jonagold. Good pollinators for Jonagold include Alkmene, James Grieve and Idared. A German pollinator chart also lists Cox, Elstar, Discovery and Gloster for Jonagold.

Example combinations for a small garden

  • Elstar + James Grieve: two diploid varieties that complement each other well.
  • Jonagold + Elstar + James Grieve: the triploid Jonagold with two pollinators that also pollinate each other.
  • Belle de Boskoop + Cox's Orange Pippin + James Grieve: a classic cooking apple with two dessert apples as pollinators.

Short on space? Choose dwarf trees or espaliers on a weak rootstock, or plant an ornamental crab apple (Malus) as a pollinator. Another option is a single tree with several varieties grafted onto it.

Help the pollinators

Fruit blossom appears early in spring, when few insects are flying yet. Make sure there are early bloomers nearby, such as crocuses, willows and blackthorn, so that bees and bumblebees are already active when your apples flower.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
Does an apple tree need a pollinator? Almost all apple varieties are largely self-sterile: pollen from the same variety germinates poorly on the stigma. Good fruit set needs pollen from a different variety. Some varieties are described as partly self-fertile, such as Elstar, Discovery, Gala and James Grieve, but even those set fruit better with a pollinator nearby.
What are apple pollination groups? Varieties are classified into flowering groups, from early to late flowering. A variety can be pollinated by varieties from the same group or from an immediately neighbouring group. Flowering must overlap; preferably no more than about six days should lie between the full bloom of two varieties. Always consult your nursery's pollination table.
Why can you not use Jonagold as a pollinator? Jonagold is a triploid variety and produces almost no usable pollen, as do Belle de Boskoop, Bramley's Seedling and Karmijn de Sonnaville. Never use triploid varieties as pollinators, and plant two diploid varieties with them so those also pollinate each other.
Which varieties go with Elstar or Jonagold in a small garden? Elstar and James Grieve are two diploid varieties that complement each other well. With Jonagold you plant two pollinators, for example Elstar and James Grieve. Good pollinators for Jonagold include Alkmene, James Grieve, Idared, Cox, Elstar, Discovery and Gloster.
What if you only have room for one apple tree? Then choose bush trees or trained forms on a weak rootstock, plant an ornamental crab as a pollinator, or choose one tree with several varieties grafted on it. Trees in neighbours' gardens can also count.

Sources