Carrots and onions as good neighbours: planning companion planting for next season

Winter is the time to draw up your vegetable garden plan for next year. Take companion planting into account while you are at it: cleverly placing crops that help each other next to one another. The best-known combination is carrots with onions. They take up little space, grow happily side by side and make life harder for each other's pests. This article explains how to approach that combination and which other neighbours work well.

Why carrots and onions help each other

Carrot fly and onion fly are two of the most troublesome pests in Dutch vegetable gardens. The females find their host plant mainly by smell. Their larvae then bore into the carrot root or onion bulb and eat it from the inside.

If you alternate the two crops, the scents mix. The strong smell of onion masks the carrots from carrot fly, and the carrot foliage confuses the onion fly. It is not watertight protection, but it does noticeably reduce the chance of damage. Researchers at Wageningen also cite carrot and onion as the classic example of a combination that keeps both crops healthy.

There is a general rule as well: a varied bed is less vulnerable than a block of a single crop. A disease or pest spreads less easily across the whole bed in mixed planting.

How to grow carrots and onions together

  • Alternate rows: a row of onions, a row of carrots, another row of onions, and so on.
  • Row spacing: about 25 cm between rows.
  • Spacing within the row: carrots 4 to 6 cm apart after thinning, onions (sets or seed-raised) 10 to 15 cm apart.
  • Timing: onion sets go into the ground from late March or April; carrots are sown from March into summer. Sow the carrots in the rows between the onions once the soil has warmed up a little.
  • Thinning: thin carrots preferably in overcast weather or in the evening, and firm the soil afterwards. The smell of bruised carrot foliage is exactly what attracts carrot fly.

A tip: onions are harvested before late carrots. After that the carrots have extra room, but the protection also disappears. If you want certainty, cover the bed with fine insect mesh. That is the most reliable protection against carrot fly.

More good neighbours for your plan

Companion planting is about more than carrots and onions. Frequently recommended combinations include:

  • Cabbage with dill: dill attracts beneficial insects such as hoverflies and parasitic wasps, which tackle cabbage pests.
  • Tomato with basil: they like the same warm spot, and basil is said to keep certain insects away.
  • Strawberry with garlic, lettuce or spinach: little competition and good use of space.
  • Sweetcorn, climbing beans and squash (the "three sisters"): the corn supports the beans, the beans fix nitrogen and the squash leaves keep the ground covered.

Bad neighbours to avoid

Some combinations work against each other. For example, avoid putting onions, garlic and leeks next to beans and peas; legumes often grow less well there. Potatoes and tomatoes are not good neighbours either, because they share the same disease: late blight (phytophthora).

Combine it with your crop rotation

Put the combinations into your growing plan, but keep crop rotation in mind too. Carrots (umbellifers) and onions (alliums) belong to different plant families, yet in many rotation schemes they share the same bed. That makes them a handy combination from a rotation point of view as well.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
Does growing carrots and onions together help against carrot fly? If you set the two crops alternately, the scents mix. The strong onion smell masks the carrot from the carrot fly, and the carrot foliage confuses the onion fly. That is not foolproof protection, but it does noticeably reduce the chance of attack.
How do you plant carrots and onions together? Set them in alternate rows, with about 25 cm between the rows. Thin carrots to 4 to 6 cm; onions stand 10 to 15 cm apart. Onion sets go in from late March or April; sow the carrots in the rows between the onions once the soil has warmed a little.
Is insect mesh better than companion planting against carrot fly? Yes, fine-mesh insect netting over the bed is the most reliable protection against carrot fly. After the onion harvest the protection of the combination also falls away, while late carrots are still in the bed.
Which crops are poor neighbours for onions? Prefer not to put onions, garlic and leeks next to beans and peas; legumes then often grow less well. Potato and tomato are also poor neighbours, because they share the same disease: late blight (phytophthora).
When is the best time to thin carrots? Prefer to thin carrots in cloudy weather or in the evening and firm the soil afterwards. It is precisely the smell of bruised carrot foliage that attracts the carrot fly.

Sources