Empty vegetable beds in winter: mulch or green manure?
After the last harvest a bed seems ready for winter. But underground life continues: worms pull plant remains down and fungi and bacteria break down organic material. Bare soil in a Dutch winter gets a lot of rain to cope with, which breaks down the structure and washes nutrients out. A covered soil fares much better. The only question is: do you lay a covering layer or let plants do the work?
Clear first, but not everything
Remove diseased plant remains and pull out perennial weeds such as couch grass and ground elder. Those do not disappear under a layer of leaves. Healthy remains may stay or serve as mulch. Also look at the soil: is it crumbly, did it already get compost this year, does water stand after a shower? That determines what the bed needs.
Option 1: a loose cover layer
Mulch is the quickest solution and fits every bed, even if it only became empty in November. Suitable material is clean autumn leaves, straw, disease-free crop waste and ripe compost.
- Spread the material loosely over the bed. If needed break large leaves somewhat so they do not cake into a wet mat.
- You need not work anything in or dig. Leave the layer on top; that way worm channels and soil structure stay intact.
- Ripe compost is dark, crumbly and smells of woodland soil. A modest layer tops up organic matter. Do not automatically give a lot of compost or manure every year; that can lead to a surplus of nutrients.
- Keep the layer away from the heart of plants that stay standing, such as winter leeks or lamb’s lettuce.
Look under the mulch now and then. Slugs like to shelter there, which can especially be a problem around young winter crops.
Option 2: a green manure
A green manure covers the soil with living plants. The roots hold the soil, loosen it and take up nutrients that would otherwise leach. In spring those are released again.
The drawback: a green manure needs growing time. Mid-November is too late for most species. Mustard and phacelia must be sown much earlier. Winter rye can often still be sown into November, and some winter vetches are also fairly late to sow. Check the sowing advice on the packet; a late sowing does not always succeed.
Also think ahead. Winter rye grows on vigorously and in spring needs time to remove before you can sow. Mustard belongs to the brassica family and can disrupt your rotation if brassicas follow.
Which do you choose?
- Bed only just empty and it is already November: choose mulch. A green manure barely gets going.
- Bed free early in autumn: a green manure is a good choice, if it fits your rotation.
- Fine sowing early in spring: choose mulch you can easily push aside, so the top layer can warm and you have a clean seed strip.
- Planting later in spring: then a green manure or thicker mulch may stay longer.
Watch wet ground
If water stands on the bed after rain, do not walk on it and certainly do not dig to work the layer in. Wet clay compacts quickly. A cover layer protects the soil, but does not solve a drainage problem. First find out where the water comes from and how it can drain, for example via raised beds or a ditch.
In spring
Push coarse mulch aside where you want to sow and leave the finer part. What remains is further processed by soil life. Mow a green manure before flowering, leave it briefly on the bed and work it in shallowly or use it as mulch. In winter do mark which beds hold overwintering crops, so you do not damage them when clearing.
Frequently asked questions
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Should you cover empty vegetable beds in winter? | Yes, bare soil has a lot of rain to deal with in a Dutch winter, which breaks down the structure and washes nutrients away. A covered soil, with mulch or a green manure, fares much better. |
| Is it too late in November for a green manure? | By mid-November it is too late for most kinds; mustard and phacelia need to have been sown well earlier. Winter rye can often still be sown into November, and some winter vetches can also be sown fairly late, but check the sowing advice on the packet. |
| Which mulch is suitable for an empty winter bed? | Suitable materials are clean autumn leaves, straw, disease-free crop waste and well-rotted compost. Spread the material loosely over the bed and do not work it in; keep the layer away from the crowns of plants that are staying put. |
| Do you choose mulch or green manure if the bed only empties in November? | Choose mulch then. A green manure barely gets going in November. If the bed was free early in autumn, a green manure is a good choice, provided it fits your crop rotation. |
| What do you do with winter mulch in spring? | Push coarse mulch aside where you want to sow and leave the finer part in place. What remains is broken down further by soil life. |