French marigolds against nematodes: what companion planting does and doesn't do

French marigolds (Tagetes) have a permanent place in many vegetable gardens, often as an edging along the tomatoes or tucked in among the cabbages. They are said to drive away nematodes and keep pests at bay. Research paints a more nuanced picture: they can genuinely help, but only if you use them the right way. Winter is a good time to make a plan for next season.

What are nematodes, and which kind does tagetes tackle?

Nematodes (eelworms) are microscopic worms that live in the soil. Most are harmless or even useful, but some species feed on plant roots. The root lesion nematode Pratylenchus penetrans is one of the most troublesome in the Netherlands. It damages potatoes, onions, carrots, salsify, chicory, beans, peas and strawberries, among others.

This is exactly the nematode that Tagetes patula actively kills. It enters the root, and the plant responds by producing substances that are lethal to it. Nematodes that don't penetrate the root that deeply, such as root-knot and cyst nematodes, are not killed. Against those species, tagetes does no more than leaving the ground bare.

Pratylenchus penetrans is found mainly on sandy and light loamy soils. On heavy clay, growing tagetes to fight nematodes therefore makes little sense.

An edging isn't enough

The biggest misconception is that a few plants among the vegetables will do. To really reduce nematode numbers, tagetes roots need to fill all the soil in the bed, and for at least three months. A narrow edging or a single plant among the tomatoes does far too little.

So use tagetes as a cover crop:

  • Choose a bed where you suspect nematode trouble, for example where carrots forked or potatoes stayed small and blemished.
  • Sow or plant the whole bed densely with Tagetes patula.
  • Let the plants grow for at least three months. Tagetes is very frost-tender, so sow or plant in good time: outdoor sowing is possible from April to the end of June.
  • At the end of the season, dig the plants in or leave them on the surface as mulch, then grow a susceptible crop such as carrots, onions or strawberries there the following year.

Which marigolds should you choose?

Not every tagetes works. Choose wild, single-flowered forms of Tagetes patula. There are also varieties bred specifically for nematode control, such as 'Ground Control'. Low, double-flowered ornamental forms hardly smell and produce almost none of the active compounds. Tagetes erecta and Tagetes tenuifolia are not suitable for this purpose.

What else do marigolds do in the vegetable garden?

Single-flowered marigolds attract beneficial insects such as hoverflies, whose larvae eat aphids. Double-flowered forms don't. Their strong scent can also confuse pests such as the cabbage white butterfly to some extent, but only if the plant stands close to the cabbage and the scent is actually released. Other aromatic plants, such as dill, coriander and basil, have a similar effect.

Marigolds don't help against potato blight or the allium leaf miner.

Crop rotation is still the best remedy

Marigolds are a useful extra, not a miracle cure. The most important measures against nematodes and many other soil problems are good crop rotation, regular compost and not walking on the beds. So simply build a tagetes crop into next year's growing plan as one of the steps in your rotation.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
Do French marigolds help against nematodes in the vegetable garden? Yes, but only against the root-lesion nematode Pratylenchus penetrans, and only if Tagetes patula roots through the whole bed for at least three months. A narrow border or a few plants among the tomatoes does too little for that. On heavy clay a tagetes crop against nematodes has little point.
Which marigolds work against nematodes? Choose wild, single-flowered forms of Tagetes patula, or varieties specially bred for nematode control, such as 'Ground Control'. Low, double ornamental forms and Tagetes erecta or Tagetes tenuifolia are not suitable for this purpose.
When do you sow tagetes as a cover crop against nematodes? Tagetes is very frost-tender, so sow or plant in good time: outdoor sowing is possible from April to the end of June. Leave the plants to grow for at least three months and the following year grow a susceptible crop such as carrot, onion or strawberry.
Do marigolds help against potato blight? No. Marigolds do not help against potato blight or leek leaf miner. Single-flowered forms do attract beneficial insects, such as hoverflies.
Is crop rotation more important than marigolds against nematodes? Yes. Marigolds are a useful extra, but not a miracle cure. The most important measures against nematodes and many other soil problems are a good crop rotation, regular compost and staying off the beds.

Sources