Grease bands against winter moth: still in time to protect your fruit trees

Do you see young leaves on your apple, pear, plum or cherry tree full of holes in spring, or leaves spun together with a small green caterpillar inside? Then the winter moth is probably the culprit. What is special about this moth is that you can tackle it best right now, in November. A sticky band around the trunk stops the females before they can lay their eggs.

The life of the winter moth

The winter moth (Operophtera brumata) has a remarkable life cycle:

  • Autumn and winter: from around the first night frost in October or November, the adult moths emerge from the soil. The males fly, but the females have no wings. They crawl up the trunk and attract the males with scent. After mating, they lay their eggs near the buds in the crown. Most activity takes place from November into January.
  • Spring: around the end of March or April, when the buds open, the caterpillars hatch. They feed on the buds, young leaves, blossom and sometimes the young fruitlets, and spin leaves together.
  • Early summer: fully grown caterpillars lower themselves to the ground on a thread and pupate in the soil until the following autumn.

Related species, such as the mottled umber and the March moth, also have wingless females. Some of them are active into spring.

Is control necessary?

Not always. In spring the caterpillars are an important food source for nesting birds such as tits. A bit of leaf damage is no problem for a healthy tree. A grease band mainly makes sense if your tree was badly eaten in previous years, or if the crop noticeably suffered. On ornamental trees, control is usually unnecessary.

How to fit a grease band

Timing

The best time is late October, before the first females crawl up. Are you later, as now in mid-November? Then put the band on as soon as possible. You may miss the first females, but the main season continues into January.

Height

Advice on the right height varies. The British RHS suggests about 45 centimetres above the ground. Dutch sources advise placing the band just below the first branches on a bush tree or espalier, and at about 1 to 1.5 metres on a half-standard or standard. More important than the exact height is that the band sits below the crown and fits tightly.

Steps

  1. Clean the trunk where the band will go. Remove loose bark, moss and dirt so that no gaps form.
  2. Wrap the band tightly around the trunk, sticky side out.
  3. Seal it properly. Tie it at the top and bottom or seal the edges so no gap remains. Even a tiny gap is enough for a female to crawl underneath. This is the most common mistake.
  4. Don't forget the tree stake. If your tree is tied to a stake, give that a grease band too. Otherwise the females will climb into the crown via the stake.
  5. Watch for other routes. If branches touch a wall, fence or neighbouring tree, females can still get up that way. A band then has little effect.

Maintenance during winter

Check the band every two to three weeks. If it is covered in leaves, dust or trapped insects, the glue loses its effect. Clean or replace it. Keep the band sticky until the end of March or early April.

Remove it in time

Take the grease band off again in early spring, by early April at the latest. If you leave it on longer, it also catches useful insects that become active then, and the glue can soak into the bark. Grease bands are not selective: they catch anything that tries to crawl across, including earwigs, which actually eat aphids in fruit trees. So only use them where winter moths are a real problem. Also choose bands or glues designed so that larger animals such as birds, bats and mice cannot get stuck in them.

Other options

  • Pheromone trap: this attracts males with scent. It mainly shows you whether the moth is active in your garden.
  • Help the birds: a nest box for tits near your fruit trees provides natural caterpillar catchers in spring.
  • No poison: pesticides against caterpillars also harm the birds that eat them, and caterpillars inside rolled-up leaves are hard to reach anyway.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
When do you put a grease band on against winter moth? The best moment is late October, before the first females crawl up. If you are later, as in mid-November, put the band on as soon as possible: the main season still runs into January.
How does a grease band work against winter moth? The females of the winter moth have no wings and crawl up the trunk to lay eggs by the buds. A grease band around the trunk stops them before they reach the crown.
How high do you place a grease band on a fruit tree? Advice varies. The RHS mentions about 45 centimetres above the ground; Dutch sources advise placing the band just below the first branch on a bush tree, and at about 1 to 1.5 metres on a half-standard or standard. More important than the exact height is that the band sits below the crown and fits tightly.
When should you take the grease band off again? Remove the grease band again in early spring, by early April at the latest. If you leave it on longer, it also catches useful insects that become active then, and the grease can soak into the bark.
Should you also put a grease band on the tree stake? Yes. If your tree is tied to a stake, give that a grease band too. Otherwise the females crawl up into the crown via the stake.

Sources