Growing carrots and onions together: what the classic combination does and doesn't do
Carrot and onion may well be the best-known example of companion planting. Tradition says they keep each other's pest flies away. Is that true? Partly. In winter, while you draw up next year's vegetable garden plan, it's a good moment to look at how to use this combination wisely and what not to count on.
The idea behind the combination
The carrot fly finds its host plant mainly by smell. It flies low over the ground, usually upwind, towards the scent of carrot foliage. Onions release strong-smelling compounds that can disrupt this searching behaviour. Conversely, the smell of carrots is said to confuse the onion fly. On top of that, both crops need little space, so they fit well side by side in alternating rows.
What research shows
An English field trial from the 1980s found less carrot fly damage in carrots grown between onions, and fewer thrips on the onions. The effect was strongest while the onions were young and virtually disappeared once the onions started forming bulbs. A Belgian strip-cropping trial in 2017, with low carrot fly pressure, could not show a clear difference. The conclusion: the combination can help, especially early in the season, but it is no guarantee. Velt also points out that many old combinations are less reliable than often claimed.
How to go about it
- Alternate rows. Sow or plant a row of onions, then one or two rows of carrots, and repeat. The more onions relative to carrots, the greater the possible effect.
- Use young onions. Onion sets or sown onions started at the same time as the carrots are still in their leafy stage during the vulnerable period of the first carrot fly flight (May–June).
- Combine with other measures. Insect mesh or fleece over the carrots remains the most reliable protection. Thin carrots preferably on a still evening and clear away the thinnings straight away, so the scent doesn't spread.
- Keep feeding in mind. Carrot and onion both need little nitrogen, which makes them good neighbours. Leeks, often recommended alongside carrots too, actually want more feeding.
Crop rotation comes first
Companion planting is variety in space; crop rotation is variety in time. Velt advises leaving several years between two crops of the onion family (onion, leek, garlic) in the same spot. So plan the carrot-and-onion combination in a section where no onions, leeks or garlic have grown in recent years.
Tip for your winter plan
Sketch the bed now with the rows alternating, and note the sowing and planting dates. That way you'll know straight away in spring where everything goes, and after harvest you can keep track of whether the carrots did better than in a separate bed.
Frequently asked questions
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Does growing carrots and onions together really help against carrot fly? | The combination can help, especially early in the season, but it is not a guarantee. An English field trial found less damage while the onions were young; the effect almost disappeared once the onions started to bulb. Insect mesh or fleece over the carrots remains the surest protection. |
| How do you set carrots and onions together in the bed? | Alternate the rows: a row of onions, then one or two rows of carrots, and repeat. The more onions there are relative to carrots, the greater the possible effect. Onion sets or sown onions that start at the same time as the carrots are still in their leafy phase during the vulnerable period of the first carrot-fly flight (May–June). |
| Why do you preferably thin carrots in the evening? | Prefer to thin carrots on a still evening and clear the thinnings away at once, so the smell of bruised foliage does not spread. That smell attracts the carrot fly. |
| Does companion planting come before crop rotation? | No. Crop rotation comes first. Leave a number of years between two crops of alliums (onion, leek, garlic) in the same place. So plan the carrot–onion combination in a plot where no onions, leeks or garlic have stood in recent years. |
| Do carrots and onions need the same feeding? | Yes, carrot and onion both need little nitrogen, which makes them good neighbours. Leeks, which are also often recommended with carrots, actually want more feed. |