Helping natural enemies overwinter: don't tidy your vegetable garden too much

In autumn many gardeners are tempted to clear everything away: stems gone, leaves gone, bare soil. Yet it is exactly in that "mess" that the creatures overwinter which will help you against aphids, caterpillars and slugs next year. If you garden organically, you let nature do the work. With a few simple choices this month you will have an army of helpers ready in spring.

Who are your helpers?

The best-known natural enemy is the ladybird, but there are many more:

  • Insects: hoverflies, lacewings, parasitic wasps, predatory bugs, earwigs and rove beetles. They or their larvae eat aphids, caterpillars and other sap-suckers.
  • Ground beetles: fast, often black beetles that hunt slugs (and their eggs), caterpillars and larvae at night. Dozens per square metre can overwinter in a good mulch layer.
  • Spiders and harvestmen: catch aphids, flies and small caterpillars.
  • Larger animals: hedgehogs, toads, shrews and birds such as blackbirds and tits eat slugs and caterpillars.

Where do they overwinter?

Insects do not disappear in winter; they hide close by as eggs, larvae, pupae or adults. Their favourite places:

  • Hollow and pithy stems, such as those of elder, bramble, sunflower and umbellifers.
  • Leaf litter under shrubs and between perennials.
  • Dead wood, bark and stones.
  • Faded flower heads and seed pods.
  • The soil itself: most wild bees and many beetles overwinter underground.

What you can do this autumn

Leave stems and leaves

Only cut back perennials and flowers around the vegetable garden in March or April. Then leave the cut stems in a heap for a while so the creatures can crawl out. Leaves can stay under shrubs, under the fruit trees and along the edges. On the vegetable beds themselves you can use leaves as mulch.

Note: do clear away diseased plant material, such as leaves with scab or potato haulm with late blight.

Build a brushwood hedge

You do not need to get rid of prunings from your fruit trees and shrubs. Drive two rows of posts into the ground, about half a metre apart, and fill the space with branches: thick wood at the bottom, thinner wood on top. Hedgehogs, toads, beetles and spiders find shelter in such a dead hedge. Choose a quiet spot along an edge or fence and top it up every year. Late autumn and winter are the ideal time for this.

Insect hotel: choose wisely

An insect hotel can help, but natural shelter is often more effective. If you do choose one, look for:

  • holes drilled into hardwood (roughly 2 to 9 mm) and hollow stems, without sharp edges;
  • no pine cones or cardboard tubes;
  • a sunny, sheltered spot at eye level;
  • leave it hanging year after year.

Leave a patch bare

Many solitary bees nest in bare, sunny ground. A small patch without mulch or plants, for example in a sandy spot, is enough.

Helping during the season too

  • Sow or plant flowers that provide nectar and pollen, such as dill, phacelia, calendula and coriander: adult hoverflies and parasitic wasps need them.
  • Don't intervene straight away when you see a few aphids. Give natural enemies time to build up a population.
  • Don't use pesticides: they often kill the helpers too.
  • Provide some water, such as a shallow dish or small pond.

Patience

A natural balance does not arise in one year. The more species live in your garden, the smaller the chance that one pest gets the upper hand. A slightly less tidy garden is a small price to pay.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
Should you tidy the vegetable garden completely in autumn? No, not too neatly. In stems, leaf litter, dead wood and the soil, the animals that will help you next year against aphids, caterpillars and slugs overwinter. Diseased plant remains, such as leaves with scab or potato haulm with late blight, you do clear away.
When do you cut back perennials if you want insects to overwinter? Cut back perennials and flowers around the vegetable garden only in March or April. After cutting, leave the stems in a heap for a while so the animals can crawl out.
How do you make a dead-hedge for overwintering animals? Drive two rows of stakes into the ground, about half a metre apart, and fill the space with branches: thick wood at the bottom, thinner wood on top. Choose a quiet spot along a border or fence; late autumn and winter are the ideal moment for this.
Where do ladybirds and other beneficial insects overwinter? Favourite places are hollow and pithy stems, leaf litter under shrubs, dead wood, bark and stones, spent flower heads and the soil itself. Most wild bees and many beetles overwinter underground.
Does an insect hotel work better than natural hiding places? An insect hotel can help, but natural hiding places are often more effective. If you still choose one, use holes drilled in hardwood and hollow stems, hang it in a sunny, wind-sheltered spot at eye level, and leave it hanging year after year.

Sources