Keeping wood pigeons off kale and Brussels sprouts: a taut net is the only real solution

In winter there's little to eat out in the fields, and then the green brassicas in the vegetable garden become an easy meal for wood pigeons. Of kale, Brussels sprouts, savoy cabbage and cavolo nero, sometimes only the leaf ribs remain. If you want to harvest your winter vegetables, now is the time to screen them off properly.

Why especially in winter?

The wood pigeon is the most common pigeon in the Netherlands. A large share stays all year round, and in winter they are joined by pigeons from the north that come to overwinter here. According to BIJ12, wood pigeons and stock doves cause feeding damage to brassicas all year. In winter, when there is little other green food, that damage is most noticeable.

Scare devices: only work briefly

Scarecrows, CDs, flashing tape and little windmills can keep pigeons away for a while. However, pigeons get used to them quickly, often within a few days. If you vary them and move them regularly, the effect lasts somewhat longer, but it isn't reliable. Fleece protects young plants temporarily, but clever pigeons sometimes pull it away or peck through it.

A net over a frame

The most effective measure is a cover net. Here's how:

  1. Build a frame. Use hoops of PVC pipe, posts with battens or a permanent fruit-cage-type structure. Kale and Brussels sprouts grow 60 cm to a metre tall; the net must not rest on the plants, or pigeons will peck straight through it.
  2. Choose a strong, fine-meshed net. Use a net with a mesh small enough to stop a pigeon. Finer insect mesh works too, and in summer it also protects against cabbage white butterflies.
  3. Stretch it taut. A taut net keeps birds out and prevents them from becoming entangled. Loose, slack nets are a trap for blackbirds, robins and hedgehogs.
  4. Seal the bottom. Lay the edges on the ground and hold them down with stones, pegs or a plank, so that no bird can crawl underneath.
  5. Make an access point. Make sure one side is easy to open for harvesting, and close it properly again afterwards.

Mind the rules

Nets must not be intended as, or function as, a means of catching birds. BIJ12 stresses that nets must be stretched taut and kept under tension, so that birds don't get underneath and become trapped. So check the net regularly, especially after storms or snow, and carefully free any animal that has become entangled.

Extra tips

  • Next year, plant winter vegetables under a net or mesh straight away: in summer this also protects against cabbage root fly and caterpillars.
  • Harvest kale regularly from the bottom up; an open plant is less attractive than one full of young leaves.
  • Clear up fallen leaves, so they don't attract pigeons.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
How do you protect kale and Brussels sprouts from wood pigeons? The most effective measure is a sturdy, fine-mesh net over a frame, stretched taut so it does not rest on the plants, with the edges fastened to the ground. Deterrents such as scarecrows and flashing tape only work briefly, because pigeons quickly get used to them.
Why do wood pigeons eat brassicas especially in winter? In winter there is little to eat in the fields, and the green brassicas in the vegetable garden then become an easy meal. A large part of the wood-pigeon population stays all year, and in winter pigeons from the north join them.
How do you stretch a pigeon net safely? Build a frame so the net does not rest on the plants, stretch it taut, close the bottom with stones, pegs or a board, and make an opening for harvesting. Loose, slack nets are a trap for blackbirds, robins and hedgehogs. Check the net regularly, especially after a storm or snow.
How high should the frame under a pigeon net be? Kale and Brussels sprouts grow 60 cm to a metre high; the net must not rest on the plants, or pigeons will peck straight through it.
Does fleece help against wood pigeons? Fleece protects young plants temporarily, but clever pigeons sometimes pull it off or peck through it. A taut net over a frame is more reliable.

Sources