Planning crop rotation in winter: how to draw up next year's growing plan
In November the vegetable garden is mostly empty, which makes it an ideal time to look ahead. You still remember exactly what grew where this year. Write it down now and turn it into a growing plan for next season. With crop rotation you move groups of vegetables to a different bed every year. That keeps the soil healthier and prevents diseases and pests from building up.
Why crop rotation works
- Fewer soil-borne diseases: many pathogens and pests specialise in one plant family and remain in the soil for years. Clubroot in brassicas and white rot in onions are well-known examples. If the same family keeps growing in the same spot, these problems pile up.
- More balanced soil fertility: each group needs different nutrients. Potatoes, for example, take up a lot of potassium, while cabbages need a lot of nitrogen. Rotating keeps the soil from being depleted in a one-sided way.
- More targeted feeding: because crops with the same needs are grouped together, you can fertilise bed by bed.
- Better soil structure: deep- and shallow-rooting crops alternate.
- Fewer weeds: leafy crops such as potatoes and squashes suppress weeds for the crop that follows.
Dividing the crops into groups
Crop rotation is based on plant families, because related crops share diseases. A common grouping:
- Brassicas (cabbage family): Brussels sprouts, kale, cauliflower, broccoli, kohlrabi, radish, turnip and swede.
- Legumes: peas, broad beans, runner beans and French beans. They fix nitrogen and are a good crop to precede brassicas.
- Onion family: onion, garlic, shallot and leek.
- Potato family (nightshades): potato and tomato. Peppers and aubergines suffer fewer problems and can be placed more freely.
- Roots and umbellifers: carrot, parsnip, celeriac, celery, fennel, parsley and beetroot.
Note: radish, turnip and swede may look like root vegetables, but they belong to the cabbage family.
Some crops fall outside the scheme. Perennial vegetables such as rhubarb and asparagus stay in the same spot for years, as do strawberries and fruit bushes. Squash, courgette, cucumber, lettuce and endive can be placed flexibly, as long as you don't keep putting them in the same place.
A four-year scheme
Divide your vegetable garden into four roughly equal sections, plus a separate area for perennial crops. Every year, move each group on by one section. An example:
| Section | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Legumes | Brassicas | Potatoes | Onions and roots |
| B | Brassicas | Potatoes | Onions and roots | Legumes |
| C | Potatoes | Onions and roots | Legumes | Brassicas |
| D | Onions and roots | Legumes | Brassicas | Potatoes |
This way brassicas always follow legumes and each family only returns to the same spot after four years. If you grow few potatoes, a three-year scheme also works. In Flanders, the organisation Velt uses a six-way division (cabbage, leaf, fruiting crops, roots, potatoes, legumes), but for most allotments four sections are easier to manage.
How long should a family stay away?
Advice varies between sources, but roughly:
- Brassicas: at least three, preferably four years or longer, because of clubroot.
- Potato and tomato: three to four years.
- Onions and leeks: three years.
- Carrots and other umbellifers: two to three years.
- Lettuce: one to two years.
Making your growing plan: practical steps
- Draw your garden on paper or in a spreadsheet and number the beds.
- Record what grew there this year, including follow-on crops and green manures. Do it now, while you still remember.
- Choose your groups and spread them over the sections so they are roughly equal in size. Also consider sun and shade: place tall crops so they don't shade lower ones.
- Move everything on by one section compared with this year.
- Plan early, main and follow-on crops for each section. After early potatoes, for example, there is still room for a green manure or an autumn crop.
- Keep your plans from every year, so that after a few years you can look back.
Feeding and liming within the rotation
Hungry crops such as brassicas and potatoes get most of the compost. Root crops, on the other hand, don't need fresh manure; it can make them fork. If you lime your soil, preferably do so in the section where the brassicas will go, and not just before potatoes, because they are more prone to scab on limy soil.
Small garden? Keep it simple
In a small garden the distance between sections may be only a metre, and then the protection against soil-borne diseases is limited. Still, it helps at least not to put families in exactly the same spot year after year. Start simply and refine your plan a little each year.
Frequently asked questions
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What is crop rotation in the vegetable garden? | With crop rotation, also called rotational cropping, you move vegetable groups to a different plot each year. That keeps the soil healthier and prevents diseases and pests from building up. |
| How long should brassicas stay off the same bed? | For brassicas the advice is at least three years, preferably four or longer, because of clubroot. Potato and tomato need three to four years, onions and leeks three years, carrots and other umbellifers two to three years. |
| Which groups do you use in a four-year scheme? | A common grouping is brassicas, legumes, the onion family, solanaceous crops such as potato and tomato, and root and umbelliferous crops. In a four-year scheme, brassicas for example always follow legumes, and each family only returns to the same spot after four years. |
| Do radish and kohlrabi belong with the root crops? | No. Radish, turnip and kohlrabi may look like root vegetables, but they belong to the brassica family. |
| Where do perennial vegetables fit in the rotation? | Perennial vegetables such as rhubarb and asparagus stay in the same place for years, as do strawberries and fruit bushes, and therefore fall outside the rotation. Pumpkin, courgette, cucumber, lettuce and endive can be placed more flexibly, as long as you do not put them in the same spot every year. |