Preventing scab on apples and pears: the fight starts with the fallen leaves
Did your apples or pears have dark, rough patches on the skin, or did the leaves drop early in summer? Then there is a good chance your tree has scab. It is a fungal disease that is common in the Netherlands, especially after wet springs. The good news: the most important measures are taken right now, in late autumn and winter. If you deal properly with the fallen leaves, you significantly lower the infection pressure in spring.
What is scab?
Scab is caused by the fungus Venturia inaequalis on apple and Venturia pirina (also written pyrina) on pear. They are two different but closely related fungi: apple scab does not infect pears and vice versa. The approach, however, is the same.
This is how to recognise it:
- Leaves: olive-green to brownish-black spots, at first somewhat velvety. Badly affected leaves drop early.
- Fruit: brown or black, corky patches. Around these spots the skin grows poorly, so fruits become misshapen or crack.
- Twigs: especially on pears, small blisters appear on young wood that later burst open and become rough (twig scab).
Light scab is mainly a cosmetic flaw; the fruit remains edible. But cracked fruits rot more quickly and store poorly.
How the fungus survives the winter
The fungus overwinters in the fallen, infected leaves, and on pears also in infected twigs. In winter and early spring, small fruiting bodies form in these leaves. From about the end of March, rain causes them to shoot spores upwards, straight towards the young leaves and blossom. If the leaves then stay wet long enough, infection follows. After two to three weeks the first spots appear, and these produce new spores that spread the disease further throughout the summer.
That is why the first infection in spring matters so much. If you can limit it, you have already won a large part of the battle.
What you can do now
1. Clear away infected leaves
In autumn and winter, carefully rake up the fallen leaves beneath diseased trees. An ordinary garden compost heap usually doesn't get hot enough in winter to kill the fungus. So it is better to dispose of these leaves in the green-waste bin, and not to use them for leaf mould or as mulch under the fruit trees.
2. Keep the area around the trunk clear
Make sure the ground around the trunk, in a radius of about 50 to 80 centimetres, is free of diseased leaves. A clean area around the trunk dries out more quickly in spring.
3. Or help the leaves break down quickly
In commercial fruit growing, the focus is also on getting the leaves to decompose as fast as possible. Lively soil life with plenty of earthworms pulls the leaves into the ground. On a lawn beneath standard trees you can mow the leaves together in dry weather and shred them with the lawnmower; shredded leaves break down faster. The fewer leaves left lying in spring, the fewer spores are released.
4. Prune out affected twigs
If during winter pruning you see twigs with blisters or rough, crusty patches, cut them out. This is particularly important on pears, because there the fungus also overwinters in the wood.
5. Open up the crown
An airy crown dries more quickly after a shower. Because the fungus needs leaves to stay wet for a long time in order to infect, an open pruning style reduces the chance of new infections.
For new planting, choose a less susceptible variety
If you are planting new trees, a less susceptible or resistant variety is the best prevention. Topaz and Santana are often mentioned as scab-resistant apples with good flavour; Santana is, however, susceptible to canker. There are also pear varieties that suffer less. Ask your nursery about varieties that do well in your area. Many popular apple varieties, such as Elstar and Cox's Orange Pippin, are in fact susceptible.
Best avoided
For fruit trees in private gardens, the measures above are the best approach. The British RHS advises home gardeners not to use fungicides, because they harm soil life and biodiversity. Besides, spraying a large tree is difficult for a home gardener. Homemade remedies are untested and are also not recommended.
Staying realistic
Spores can be carried over long distances by the wind. If there are other infected trees nearby, clearing up helps less than it does for an isolated tree. Still, it is worth the effort: every amount of leaves you remove or help decompose means fewer spores in spring.
Frequently asked questions
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| How do you prevent scab on apple and pear? | The most important measure is to clear fallen, infected leaves carefully in autumn and winter, so the fungus cannot overwinter in them. Dispose of this leaf litter in the garden-waste bin and do not use it for leaf mould or as mulch under the fruit trees. An airy crown also dries more quickly after rain. |
| Is an apple with scab still edible? | Light scab is mainly a cosmetic fault; the fruit remains edible. Cracked fruit, however, rots more quickly and stores poorly. |
| Does apple scab also overwinter in the twigs? | The fungus overwinters in fallen, infected leaves, and on pear also in infected shoots. If during winter pruning you see shoots with blisters or rough, scabby patches, cut them out; this is especially important on pear. |
| Which apple varieties are less susceptible to scab? | Topaz and Santana are often named as scab-resistant apples with good flavour; Santana is, however, susceptible to canker. Many popular varieties, such as Elstar and Cox's Orange Pippin, are in fact susceptible. |
| Does an ordinary compost heap kill scab spores? | An ordinary garden compost heap usually does not get hot enough in winter to kill the fungus. It is therefore better to dispose of infected leaves in the garden-waste bin. |
Sources
- https://edepot.wur.nl/120490
- https://fruitbomen.net/informatie/blog/najaarsschoonmaak-in-de-boomgaard
- https://www.bongerdgrooteveen.nl/ziekten/Schurft_Venturia_inaequalis/Schurft_Venturia_inaequalis.php
- https://delphy.nl/wp-content/uploads/Fruitteelt/Handleiding.-Schurfbeheersing-Werk-actief-aan-een-bladvrije-start-in-het-nieuw-seizoen.pdf
- https://www.rhs.org.uk/disease/apple-and-pear-scab