Winter pruning apple and pear trees: how to keep the crown open and productive

Now that the leaves have fallen from your apple and pear trees, you can clearly see the structure of the crown again. That makes winter the best time for the annual pruning session. With calm, targeted winter pruning you keep the tree healthy, limit its size and get better fruit. The most important advice up front: rather too little than too much.

When to prune

Winter pruning is done while the tree is dormant: after leaf fall and before the buds break in spring. In the Netherlands that is roughly from November to early March. Some sources advise waiting until December, when the tree is fully dormant; pruning in November is fine as long as all the leaves have fallen.

Choose a dry day without frost. In hard frost the wood is brittle and easily tears around the cut. In rain or fog, pruning wounds stay damp for a long time, which encourages infection.

Note: this advice applies to apples and pears. Stone fruit such as plums, cherries, peaches and apricots should not be pruned in winter but in summer, when they are less at risk of infection.

Which trees?

This approach is meant for established, free-standing trees: bush trees on a short trunk and half-standards or standards, usually from four or five years after planting. Young trees are pruned mainly to build up a good framework. Trained forms such as espaliers, cordons and fans are largely pruned in summer.

The aim: an open crown

You are aiming for an open, goblet-shaped crown with well-spaced main branches. That lets light reach all parts of the tree and lets the wind blow through. The result is better-coloured fruit and fewer diseases, because leaves and fruit dry more quickly after a shower. A well-known image: a pigeon should be able to fly through the crown.

How much to remove?

In routine winter pruning, remove about 10 to 20 per cent of the crown, spread evenly all round. If you prune too hard, the tree responds with a mass of vigorous, upright shoots: watershoots. They bear no fruit and close up the crown again. That just creates more work for next year.

Step by step

  1. Dead, diseased and damaged wood first. Cut or saw out dead branches, broken branches and branches with canker or scab patches, back into healthy wood.
  2. Crossing branches. Branches that rub against each other cause wounds. Keep the best-placed, outward-growing one and remove the other.
  3. Inward-growing branches. Remove strong shoots growing towards the centre of the tree. Weak, short shoots (up to about 20 centimetres) can be left.
  4. Watershoots. Remove the upright, vigorous shoots completely, as close as possible to where they arise. Don't leave stubs, because new shoots will grow from them.
  5. Low-hanging branches. Branches that grow low and downwards and receive little light should be cut back to a higher branch or to the trunk.
  6. Shorten last year's growth. Shorten the new growth at the ends of the main branches by a quarter to a third, just above an outward-facing bud. This encourages branching and the formation of fruiting wood.
  7. Leave young side shoots. Leave young side shoots unpruned so that they can form flower buds in their second year. Only remove them if they cross or are too crowded.
  8. Thin out old fruiting spurs. On older trees the short, knobbly fruiting shoots (spurs) can become overcrowded. Thin them out until they are about 10 to 15 centimetres apart.

Mind the fruiting type

Most apples and pears bear their fruit on short spurs along the branches. Some varieties bear fruit (also) at the tips of the shoots, such as Bramley's Seedling and Discovery. With those varieties you need to be extra careful when shortening young shoots, otherwise you will cut off the flower buds. On such trees it is better to cut an old, overlong branch back to a younger side shoot.

Good tools

  • Secateurs for thin twigs.
  • Loppers for thicker branches.
  • Pruning saw for thick branches.
  • A sturdy ladder, preferably a tripod ladder that stands steadily on uneven ground.
  • Gloves and safety glasses against twigs and sawdust.

Make sure everything is sharp and clean. Blunt blades leave ragged wounds that heal poorly.

Trees that have grown too big

If your tree grows vigorously every year despite light pruning, consider additional summer pruning between mid-August and mid-September. That reduces vigour. If a tree really needs to be smaller, you can shorten larger branches by up to a third, back to a strong, outward-facing side branch. A badly neglected tree should be rejuvenated in stages, spread over several winters.

Frequently asked questions

Question Answer
When do you winter-prune apple and pear trees? Do the winter pruning when the tree is dormant: after leaf fall and before the buds break in spring. In the Netherlands that is roughly from November to early March. Choose a dry, frost-free day.
Can you prune a plum tree in winter too? No. This advice applies to apple and pear. Stone fruits such as plum, cherry, peach and apricot are not pruned in winter but in summer, because they then have less chance of infection.
How much wood do you remove in a normal winter prune? In a normal winter prune, take out about 10 to 20 percent of the crown, evenly distributed all round. If you prune too hard, the tree responds with a thicket of vigorous, upright water shoots that give no fruit.
What are water shoots and should you prune them out? Water shoots are upright, vigorous shoots. Remove them completely, as close as possible to their origin, and do not leave stubs, because new shoots will grow from those.
Should you shorten young shoots on every apple variety? Not always. Most apples and pears fruit on short spurs, but some varieties also fruit at the tips of the shoots, such as Bramley's Seedling and Discovery. With those varieties you must be especially careful about shortening young shoots, or you will prune the flower buds away.

Sources